Unable to get NDS ROM version

[shsoya]

Revision

<7278>

Issue Description

<Please fill in>

When the issue occurs

<2012/08/23 19:02:58 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] ATR: 3F 7F 13 25 03 33 B0 11 69 FF 4A 50 50 00 00 49 56 01 00 00
2012/08/23 19:02:59 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] Maximum frequency for this card is formally 5 Mhz, clocking it to 4.80 Mhz
2012/08/23 19:03:00 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] Unable to get NDS ROM version.
2012/08/23 19:03:00 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] classD0 ins4C: failed - sending boxid failed
2012/08/23 19:03:00 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] card system not supported
2012/08/23 19:03:00 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] Normal mode failed, reverting to Deprecated Mode
2012/08/23 19:03:04 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] ATR: 3F 7F 13 25 03 33 B0 11 69 FF 4A 50 50 00 00 49 56 01 00 00
2012/08/23 19:03:04 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] Maximum frequency for this card is formally 5 Mhz, clocking it to 4.80 Mhz
2012/08/23 19:03:07 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] card system not supported
2012/08/23 19:03:07 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] card initializing error>

How the issue is reproducable

<Please fill in>

<Don't forget to ATTACH (NOT post here as text) a log file of oscam in debug mode (start oscam with -d255) and to remove the brackets around the fields! Otherwise, your ticket will be closed as you seem to be unable to read.>

[lintendo]

your problem is

2012/08/23 19:03:00 9DDFD70 r d2h [smartreader] classD0 ins4C: failed - sending boxid failed

not

Unable to get NDS ROM version!

check your boxid or do a log 4

[lattjo]

Please make a debug log, start oscam with -d255.

It's clear what commit that triggered it but instead of reverting it we might be able to make a better patch if we get a debug log.

[Mandos]

Here is a log from me with the German S|<y V13.

[Mandos]

I seem to be having the same problem as lintendo, and it looks as if this patch was the reason for all those tickets from PauluZ. Back to 7277, which works fine with the same config. BTW, I do not see any difference that might have caused the "classD0 ins4C: failed - sending boxid failed". The transmits and receives directly before that line are identical for SVN versions 7277 and 7278; the only difference is a bit before that, the failed attempt to read the ROM version. I'll add a log from 7277 for comparison.

[Mandos]

Log from SVN 7277, everything OK, for comparison.

[lattjo]

I tried to do a fix in r7280, close the ticket if it works.

[lintendo]

I saw the log, but i think that I missing something

first of all i don't understand why v13 has answered in right mode at ins02 but oscam give error.. see the log posted previously:

D0 02 00 00 08
334	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
335	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    D0 02 00 00 08
336	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
337	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    D0 02 00 00 08
338	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
339	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
340	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    02
341	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Received:
342	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    02
343	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
344	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    50 31 54 56 01 00 41 37
345	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Received:
346	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    50 31 54 56 01 00 41 37 

v13 answer 50 31 54 56 01 00 41 37 -->P1TV-10A7

other thing:if we check with

if(cmd_exists(reader,ins02)) {

maybe oscam only with 1 or 2 card in the word will support the ins, bcs is not listed in 7401
for example italian cards don't list ins02 as supported in 7401, but ins02 should be universal in all ndz crd released

another interesting thing that i saw in log

358	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] write to cardreader
359	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    D0 4C 00 00 09 12 34 56 78 03 00 00 00 04
360	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
361	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    D0 4C 00 00 09
362	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
363	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    D0 4C 00 00 09
364	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
365	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
366	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    4C
367	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Received:
368	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    4C
369	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
370	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    12 34 56 78 03 00 00 00 04
371	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
372	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    12 34 56 78 03 00 00 00 04
373	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
374	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
375	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    90
376	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Received:
377	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    90
378	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
379	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    00
380	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] IFD: Received:
381	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    00
382	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] Answer from cardreader:
383	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780    90 00
384	2012/08/23 18:03:40   628780 r v13_smargo [smartreader] classD0 ins4C: failed - sending boxid failed

oscam tells us classD0 ins4C: failed.. but the reader answers correctly!!

i suspect a bug in do_cmd or near there

[Mandos]

@lattjo: just tested SVN 7281. Looks good so far, the V13 card works again. No more messages about the ROM or the boxid.

[shsoya]

fixes SVN 7281
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] Answer from cardreader:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 26 02 3F 00 90 00
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] write to cardreader
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 D0 4C 00 00 09 00 48 03 00 00 00 04
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 D0 4C 00 00 09
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 D0 4C 00 00 09
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 4C
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 4C
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 00 48 03 00 00 00 04
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 00 48 03 00 00 00 04
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 90
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 90
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 00
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 00
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] Answer from cardreader:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 90 00
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] write to cardreader
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 D0 58 00 00 4A
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 D0 58 00 00 4A
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 D0 58 00 00 4A
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 58
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 58
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:46 90B31A8 15 48 25 00 48 05 33 FF B3 62 00 60 4C 00
............

2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] Answer from cardreader:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 06 90 00
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] write to cardreader
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 D0 74 0E 00 06
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 D0 74 0E 00 06
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 D0 74 0E 00 06
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Transmit succesful
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 74
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 74
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 1B 04 FF FF FF FF
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 1B 04 FF FF FF FF
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 90
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 90
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IO: SR: Receive:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 00
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] IFD: Received:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 00
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] Answer from cardreader:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 1B 04 FF FF FF FF 90 00
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] parental lock setting: FF FF FF FF
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] type: VideoGuard Unknown Card, caid: 09C1
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] serial: ########, BoxID: ########, baseyear: 1997
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] ready for requests
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [smartreader] found cardsystem videoguard2
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] card detected
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] type: VideoGuard Unknown Card
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] write to cardreader
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 D0 76 00 7F 02
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] IFD: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 D0 76 00 7F 02
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] IO: SR: Transmit:
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 D0 76 00 7F 02
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] IFD: Transmit succesful
2012/08/24 15:13:47 90B31A8 r d2h [videoguard2] IO: SR: Receive:

[lintendo]

this new patch should show rom version also for v13 without error.
Please test

we talk about on http://www.streamboard.tv/wbb2/thread.php?threadid=34848

[Mandos]

Log from SVN 7282 with patch from lintendo

[Mandos]

@lintendo: tried your patch (patch complained about a malformed patch at line 32, so I edited reader-videoguard2.c manually), and it seems to work fine.
The data to and from the card seems to be the same as in SVN 7277 (including the "D0 02 00 00 08" sequence being written to the card, see lines 357 to 381 in my latest log; these are missing with the unmodified SVN 7282), but the card initializes fine. I do not get any "Unable to get NDS ROM version." or "classD0 ins4C: failed - sending boxid failed".

Btw, is it possible to display the NDS ROM version or use it in any way? Is it the sequence "50 31 54 56 01 00 41 37"?

[lintendo]

tnx to Mandos for testing with v13

@lattjo and other devs
now oscam shows rom version in entitlements page and in log for all vg2 card without error
also if it isn't listed in ins7401.
The problem was do_cmd that can't find the ins on supported list of ins7401

[lintendo]

ins 02 working also for v13

[lattjo]

Your solution works but I think maybe I can patch do_cmd instead, it can be done, I tested and it works as well. But you solution + a comment why write_cmd is used is also ok.

I will think about it and commit something soon.

[lintendo]

no problem ;)

but in my opinion make no sense, in this case, call function_a(function_b) that returns value of function_b, if i need this last one.

less work for oscam, more efficiency:)

i'm reading the oscam's vg code and more functions need to be optimized..
(I'm not a professional programmer but I can understand if the code is not well written.. or written by many people )

[BigGyros]

maybe someone can add just the part where the rom version is shown in the logs? i have add just this part as a patch from lintendos patch.

[lattjo]

Added latest patch in r7288