Opened 11 years ago

Closed 11 years ago

#3094 closed defect (invalid)

0100:00006a ECM whitelist & ECM headerWhitelist defect?

Reported by: TGFS Owned by:
Priority: trivial Component: General
Severity: low Keywords:
Cc: theparasol Sensitive: no

Description

Revision

OSCAM 1.20-unstable_svn build #8090
(it happens in all revisions)

Issue Description

The card locks if i would record 3 simulcrypt channels and watch one of them.

"you" (theparasol)
Changed 3 days ago by theparasol:

This all is known already. What not known is how to fix / workaround it. We cannot change the firmware of the card, if it locks: it locks. The 4 channel lock was public spread knowledge not based on facts, you cannot take it for granted.

You don't need to change the card It's a fact you can watch 4 channels @ once. Do i record 3 normal SIDS and watch one there is no problem. If i record simulcrypt channels 3 of them and watch one there you have the problem it gets a lock.

reminder:
"Satelliet-tv-provider CanalDigitaal stelt met de maatregel te willen voorkomen dat mensen hun tv-signaal via het internet tegen betaling aan anderen beschikbaar stellen. Het aantal clients dat van één CanalDigitaal-smartcard gebruik kan maken, is daarom beperkt tot vier. De maatregel is dinsdag ingegaan, bevestigt een woordvoerder van CanalDigitaal tegen TotaalTV.

Klanten met een gecertificeerde CanalDigitaal-ontvanger hoeven geen maatregelen te nemen; zij hebben een software-update gekregen. Wie een Linux-satellietontvanger heeft, moet de firmware updaten zodat het aantal streams wordt vastgesteld op vier; gebeurt dat niet, dan kunnen maximaal twee toestellen op hetzelfde moment van de CanalDigitaal-verbinding gebruikmaken.

Opnemen van tv geldt als één aparte stream, dus als er wordt opgenomen, kunnen daarnaast nog maar drie streams op hetzelfde moment worden bekeken. Het terugkijken van een met een Linux-ontvanger opgenomen tv-uitzending geldt bovendien als een aparte uitzending, omdat de ontvanger deze moet decoderen.
"

When the issue occurs

the mainproblem is this:

I do have it only with simulcrypt SIDS on card 0100:00006a and my beliefs are you could bould something for it in OSCAM.
If i have 4 normal SIDS @ one card
example:

  • 1B6C : RTL 4 HD
  • 5217 : RTL 5 HD
  • 17CA : SBS 6 HD
  • 5212 : RTL 7 HD

and if i would record RTL4HD, RTL5HD, SBS6HD and watch RTL7HD there is no problem at all only if you take 4 simulcrypt channels like:

example:

  • 1419 : NG Wild
  • 1421 : Eurosport HD
  • 1B62 : Discovery HD Showcase
  • 141F : History HD

A problem that i think it could be is this option not working fine

•ECM whitelist: 0100@00006A:64
•ECM headerWhitelist: 813061006A00075C00,803061006A00075C00

Why? Because if you take 0100@00006A:64 this is only for Canaldigitaal for no other provider. So if there were no ECM whitelist / ECM headerWhitelist than i can think ok i understand maybe this examples. Now there is ECM whitelist / ECM headerWhitelist then can't be that you get a lock.

There must be a solution Dr. theparasol

Knowledge is realizing that the street is one-way, wisdom is looking both directions anyway

Kind regards, TGFS

How the issue is reproducable

not

I don't have to attachments with this... check ticket #3059

Change History (3)

comment:1 by theparasol, 11 years ago

There is no solution. Only 4 ecms are send to the card and it locks anyway for these channels. Whatever the reason might be its not a flaw in oscam. Remember its the card that makes the locking rules not oscam.

comment:2 by ni hao, 11 years ago

The function of ecm(header)whitelist has no influence to (omit) card lock. Card lock is a result of the software in the chip at the card and the amount of SIDs in use at the same time. As the parasol already wrote card lock has nothing to do with oscam nor can oscam do anything about it. Therefor there is no defect in ecm(header)whitelist and thus is this ticket invalid.

comment:3 by ni hao, 11 years ago

Priority: blockertrivial
Resolution: invalid
Severity: highlow
Status: newclosed
Note: See TracTickets for help on using tickets.